[OS X TeX] Indexes

[Simon Spiegel]

On 16.12.2005, at 15:26, William Adams wrote:

> On Friday, December 16, 2005, at 08:35 AM, Simon Spiegel wrote:
>
>> coming near the end of my thesis, I started thinking about  
>> creating an
>> index. Now there's of course makeindex et al. but I find the idea of
>> going through 300 pages and add \index everywhere not very  
>> attractive.
>> Not only will this take a lot of time, but the tex file will be quite
>> unreadable in the end. I wondered if no one ever came up with some
>> sort of tool which would half-automatize indexing. I can think of  
>> some
>> simple GUI tool which would list all terms appearing in a latex file
>> and where you could chose which \index entry should be added for  
>> which
>> term (the next thing would of course be that the editor would hide  
>> all
>> \index entries…).
>>
>> I know there are things like jurabib's authorformat=indexed which
>> automatically creates an index for quoted authors but this doesn't
>> help me a lot because I use bibtex for handling my bibliography  
>> and my
>> fimography, and if I quote a filme jurabib will make an index entry
>> for the director although I'd need the film title in this case.
>>
>> So, how do people handle indexes?
>
> You can't automate the production of a topical index.
>
> You can automate the production of a concordance, which is far less
> useful, which is what you're describing in the latter part of your
> first paragraph.
>
> Adding index terms doesn't make .tex source unattractive, indeed, I
> find it helps one in understanding related concepts and makes for a
> better presentation.
>
> The index for _The LaTeX Companion 2nd Edition_ was prepared by a
> professional indexer from a .pdf of the text run out w/ line nos.,
> using said line nos. as locators. Once the index was compleat and
> approved, the indexer dumped it out in line no. order. Frank  
> Mittelbach
> then went through his entire set of source documents and up-dated the
> index entries so as to produce what the indexer had created. It is  
> left
> as an exercise for the reader to track down a copy of both editions  
> and
> compare the automatically-generated index in the first with the
> professionally done index in the second.
>
> William
> (whose wife scored a 98 in the USDA undergraduate indexing course and
> is now working on the advanced course)
>

Being not an undergraduate indexer, I don't really understand what  
you're saying. Maybe this is just a language problem… What I want is  
some sort of "index" (for lack of a better word) where one can easily  
find names, film titles, important terms etc. Maybe this is what you  
mean by concordance… Of course, this can't be fully automatized, but  
some sort of in advance preparation would certainly be possible IMO.

simon

--
Simon Spiegel
Mutschellenstr. 97
8038 Zürich

Telephon: ++41 43 535 81 71
Mobophon: ++41 76 459 60 39

http://www.simifilm.ch

"I have never been certain that the moral of the Icarus myth is, as  
is generally accepted, 'don't fly too high', or whether it might also  
be thought of as: 'forget about the wax and feathers, and do a better  
job on the wings." Stanley Kubrick

------------------------- Info --------------------------
Mac-TeX Website: http://www.esm.psu.edu/mac-tex/
          & FAQ: http://latex.yauh.de/faq/
TeX FAQ: http://www.tex.ac.uk/faq
List Archive: http://tug.org/pipermail/macostex-archives/